Advance Directives
Taking care of yourself and your family means making
decisions about medical care while your health allows you to
do so.
Although death comes to everyone, many of us tend to fear
its approach and may avoid confronting the issues
surrounding the end of life. Nevertheless, it is important
for each person to document his or her wishes in writing
prior to serious illness or physical or mental disability.
Otherwise, those wishes may not be known and cannot be
honored, thus creating an unnecessary burden for loved ones.
What are advance directives?
Advance directives are written instructions in the form of a
living will and/or durable power of attorney for health
care. Advance directives do not go into effect until the
signer loses decision-making capacity.
A living will (health care treatment directive) is a legal
document that communicates a person's desires about
withholding and/or withdrawing medical treatment in the
event that he or she suffers from an incurable and terminal
condition. Living wills outline in advance the treatment
choices and instructions to be followed by caregivers if the
signer cannot take part in making health care decisions. It
is called a 'living will' because it must be signed with the
same type of formality as a regular will but its provisions
take effect before death.
A living will:
- may spell out specific measures that the person wishes,
or does not wish, to have taken to extend life when he or
she is clearly dying
- may specify the use or non-use of breathing machines,
feeding tubes, oxygen, intravenous fluids, or other
medications
- may list specific illnesses or conditions (persistent
vegetative state, coma, terminal illness with no hope of
recovery or cure, end-stage dementia) under which the
provisions of the living will are to go into effect.
A living will must be witnessed to be legal, and a person
must be competent when he or she signs it. Requirements
vary from state to state, but usually the witnesses must be
unrelated to the patient, cannot be creditors or heirs to
the patient's estate, and cannot be the patient's doctor.
It is wise to prepare a living will at a time when you are
healthy, not when you have been seriously ill or are in the
hospital.
Most states have laws that recognize advance directives.
Not all states do, however, and living wills may not always
be binding. Some states do not recognize living wills that
have been drafted in other states. You need to be familiar
with the laws in your state.
A durable power of attorney for health care (DPAHC)
designates a family member or friend to follow the person's
wishes and to make medical decisions on his or her behalf
should the signer lose decision-making capacity. It is more
flexible and comprehensive than the living will, and is
regarded by some as preferable to it.
For this document to be legal, the person must be competent
at the time he or she signs it. Anyone with a progressive
brain disorder such as Parkinson's disease or Alzheimer's
disease may wish to draw up the DPAHC papers early in the
illness. The duty of an agent in the durable power of
attorney for health care is to follow the signer's wishes.
In states that recognize such documents, families and
physicians can not override a living will or the agent of a
DPAHC.
Once signed, such documents should be kept in a safe place,
but not in a safe deposit box where they may not be
accessible when they are needed. It is a good idea to
discuss your wishes with your friends, family members, and
your physician. Giving these people copies of your living
will or DPAHC also is advisable. That way, should you
become incapacitated, others will have access to the
documents that express your wishes.
Sample forms for writing your living will, a durable power
of attorney, and a Health Care Treatment Directive are
available with this handout. If you want copies of those
sample forms and they were not provided with this handout,
ask for them. They are only samples, however, and may not
conform to the laws in your state.
The Midwest Bioethics Center (816-756-1735) provides
information about advanced directives nationwide. Choice in
Dying will provide a copy of state-specific advance
directives free to anyone who writes the organization
(Choice in Dying, 200 Varick Street, New York, NY 10014) or
calls (1-800-989-WILL). Your state health department, local
hospitals, or state bar also may be able to provide you with
state-specific advance directives. You may wish to consult
your lawyer about advance directives and drawing up a
durable power of attorney for health care or a living will
and a regular will that conform to the laws in your state.
What happens if the person is already incompetent or
physically unable to manage his or her own financial and
medical affairs?
Some older people are unable to manage their own affairs due
to medical illness or a mental impairment. The central
issue is whether that person can understand and make
decisions involving medical and financial choices. A person
can be confused about time and place, but nonetheless may be
able to understand his or her choices if they are carefully
explained. It is also possible for an older person to be
capable of making decisions about his or her health but not
about finances. Physicians are often asked to evaluate the
competency of a patient, but a doctor can only make a
medical determination about someone's decision-making
ability. A court must make any legal determination about
competency.
All states allow the courts to establish limited
guardianships (also called conservatorships) and unlimited
guardianships.
A limited guardianship allows the appointed guardian to make
decisions for someone in areas where the court has
determined that the person lacks the ability to function.
This type of arrangement is often made for managing
finances. Someone judged incompetent for financial purposes
is still able to make decisions regarding his or her health.
An unlimited guardianship removes all rights of the
individual to vote, to decide where to live, and to manage
his or her money and health. That person is said to be
incompetent for all purposes and receives the protections
generally given to a child.
What is the meaning of 'resuscitate' and 'do not resuscitate
(DNR)?'
If you are in a clinic, hospital, or nursing home, you may
be asked to sign a code status sheet. This will indicate to
the staff what measures, if any, you want taken should you
be found not breathing and without a heartbeat. Code status
may be changed at any time.
Cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) was developed in the
1960s as a way to prevent sudden and unexpected death. When
administered quickly, it is generally effective for heart
attacks, drownings, drug overdoses, and similar acute
situations. However, CPR is not generally as effective for
people with chronic and severe illnesses or where death is
expected to occur soon.
A full code means that you want everything possible to be
done to revive you. This includes administering chest
compressions, electrical shocks, and medication (to start
your heart) and putting you on a ventilator (a machine to
keep you breathing). This type of CPR has the most success
but is still less successful for people with chronic medical
conditions. Some people request a limited code, which
usually excludes being put on a ventilator and is much less
often successful.
When CPR is medically futile, your doctor should explain
why. In those cases, a no code order (DNR, for Do Not
Resuscitate) may be written. It is important to recognize
that a DNR order only pertains to not having CPR and does
not limit other types of treatment. A person should receive
all indicated medical and nursing care, even when CPR would
be of no benefit. A discussion with your doctor about CPR
is an excellent opportunity to review your overall medical
condition and treatment plan.
For samples of advance directives, see
Durable Power of Attorney for Health Care Decisions
Health Care Treatment Directive
Living Will Declaration
|